www.nycsubway.org

Olympics (was Re: Times Square) (709493)

[ Read Responses | Post a New Response | Return to the Index ]
[ First in Thread | Next in Thread ]

Posted by Rail Blue on Wed May 19 07:57:18 2004, in response to Re: Times Square,
posted by oakapple on Tue May 18 18:09:22 2004.

The Olympics bid is widely considered a long-shot.

Not least by the IOC. Realistically, it's a two horse race between Paris and Madrid, although the only decision which would surprise me would be one in favour of Moscow. The IOC seem to think similarly, their overall ratings of the five cities being as follows:

1 Paris 8.5
2 Madrid 8.3
3 London 7.6
4 New York 7.5
5 Moscow 6.5

This breaks down thus:

ACCOMMODATION
1= London 10.0
1= Paris 10.0
1= New York 10.0
4 Madrid 8.4
5 Moscow 7.4

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
1= London 8.6
1= Madrid 8.6
1= Paris 8.6
4= New York 7.6
4= Moscow 7.6

EXPERIENCE FROM PAST SPORTS EVENTS
1 Paris 9.0
2 New York 8.0
3 Madrid 7.4
4 Moscow 7.0
5 London 6.8

FINANCE
1= London 8.0
1= Madrid 8.0
1= Paris 8.0
4 New York 7.5
5 Moscow 7.2

GENERAL INFRASTRUCTURE
1 Madrid 8.5
2 Paris 7.8
3= New York 7.0
3= London 7.0
5 Moscow 6.8

GOVERNMENT SUPPORT, LEGAL ISSUES AND PUBLIC OPINION
1 Madrid 8.3
2 Paris 8.0
3 Moscow 7.5
4 London 7.2
5 New York 7.1

OLYMPIC VILLAGE
1 Madrid 8.7
2 Paris 8.3
3 Moscow 8.0
4 London 8.0
5 New York 7.7

OVERALL PROJECT AND LEGACY
1= Paris 9.0
1= Madrid 9.0
3= New York 8.0
3= London 8.0
5 Moscow 7.0

SAFETY AND SECURITY
1 Paris 8.3
2 London 7.7
3 Madrid 7.4
4 New York 7.2
5 Moscow 6.4

SPORTS VENUES
1 Madrid 8.7
2 Paris 8.0
3 New York 7.7
4= Moscow 7.1
4= London 7.1

TRANSPORT CONCEPT
1 Madrid 9.0
2 Paris 8.0
3= New York 6.7
3= London 6.7
5 Moscow 6.2

In terms of transport, the Madrid bid is pretty amazing. There's a metro extension, two new suburban rail stations, new high speed rail lines, and an expansion of Madrid Airport.

I can't find any plans for infrastructure improvements in Paris, but they don't really need much, as their Métro and RER are excellent to begin with. The Moscow site also seems vague.

London of course has come up with some really dumb ideas, like extending the East London Line to run from nowhere much to nowhere much. There's also a totally imbecilic idea of running high-speed shuttles from London St Pancras to Stratford International whilst maintaining a whole Eurostar and High-Speed Kent service. The IOC were totally scathing about London's infrastructure: the railway network is "often obsolete" and the IOC want huge capacity and safety upgrades; they've also smelt a rat at the dispersed nature of the sites, some over 30 miles from the Olympic Village, and have deemed the supposed average speed of buses between them at 35mph "unrealistic"; furthermore they've noticed that the main arterial roads are at capacity already.

I don't think anyone needs any filling in on NY's transport plan.


Responses

Replying to posts on SubTalk are disabled at this time.